Portable Buddy or Big Buddy, which heater for your garage
Both are Mr. Heater radiant portables with a low-oxygen shut-off and a tip-over switch, certified for indoor use with fresh air. The Portable Buddy tops out at 9,000 BTU in the $ band, while the Big Buddy doubles that to 18,000 BTU in the $$ band.
The Portable Buddy for you at the bench, the Big Buddy for the bay around you
If you want warm hands and a warm back at one workbench in a one-car garage, the Portable Buddy does that for the least money. Mr. Heater rates it at 9,000 BTU for about 225 sq ft, which is spot heat rather than a warm room.
The Big Buddy suits a two-car garage you work in on weekends. At 18,000 BTU it is rated for about 450 sq ft, takes two 1 lb cylinders, and runs a full day or more from a 20 lb tank that stays outside.
Both made our best propane garage heater shortlist, the Big Buddy as our top pick and its little sibling as the budget spot heater. The Big Buddy also meets the Blue Flame wall heater, and the wall heater faces an 85,000 BTU torpedo.
Portable Buddy and Big Buddy side by side
Figures come from the two Amazon.com listings and from Mr. Heater’s manuals, which we mark. Where the weights disagree, the table gives both.
| Feature | Portable Buddy (MH9BX) | Big Buddy (MH18B) |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Portable radiant, certified for indoor use | Portable radiant, certified for indoor use, no fan (“NF”) |
| Heat output | 4,000 or 9,000 BTU/h | Three steps, 4,000 / 9,000 / 18,000 BTU/h |
| Rated area | Up to about 225 sq ft | Up to about 450 sq ft |
| Fuel and tank | A single 1 lb cylinder, or a hose to an outdoor 20 lb tank | Up to two 1 lb cylinders, or a hose to a 20 lb tank kept outdoors |
| Run time | 2.4 h (high) to 5.4 h (low) per 1 lb cylinder, per the listing | 1.5–6 h on one 1 lb, 3–12 h on two, 24–108 h on 20 lb (manual) |
| Power needed | None, piezo igniter | None, piezo igniter |
| Thermostat | None, two settings | None, three settings |
| Venting and fresh air | No flue; 9 sq in opening (manual) | No flue; 18 sq in near the ceiling and again near the floor (manual) |
| Safety devices | Low-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch | Low-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch |
| Install | None, it stands on the floor | None, it stands on the floor |
| Weight | 7.1 lb (listing), 10.6 lb (Mr. Heater) | 13.01 lb per the listing, 17.1 lb per Mr. Heater |
| Price band | $ (under $150) | $$ ($150 to $300) |
| Warranty | 1-year on the listing, 3-year on the Mr. Heater site | 3-year limited (listing) |
Heat and garage size
A one-car garage typically runs about 240–300 sq ft and a two-car garage about 400–600 sq ft. The Portable Buddy’s 225 sq ft rating falls short of even the smaller one, and the Big Buddy’s 450 sq ft covers a modest two-car bay in mild weather.
Those ratings assume insulation and a gentle chill, so read them as the top of the range. One common estimate takes the volume in cubic feet, times the degrees you want to add, times 0.133, and an uninsulated garage needs noticeably more. Our garage heater sizing guide walks you through it.
Radiant heat bends the math a little. A Buddy warms what it faces, you and the bench, long before it warms the air, so a small heater aimed at your work spot feels warmer than its rating suggests.
Round goes to the Big Buddy, with twice the heat and a high setting the small one lacks.
Fuel and running
On 1 lb cylinders both drink fast. The Portable Buddy lists 2.4 hours on high per cylinder, and the Big Buddy manual lists 1.5 to 6 hours for one. With a single 1 lb cylinder the Big Buddy runs only on low or medium, so its high setting needs two cylinders or a hose.
A 20 lb tank on a Buddy hose changes the picture. The Big Buddy manual gives 24 to 108 hours, and plain arithmetic (about 432,000 BTU in the tank divided by 9,000) puts the Portable Buddy near 48 hours on high. The tank stays outside, never in the garage.
Below about 20 °F, both manuals say run times drop, and Mr. Heater recommends the 20 lb tank in the cold. Our propane tank setup guide shows which hose goes with which tank.
Round goes to the Portable Buddy on fuel per hour, the Big Buddy on choice of cylinders.
Setup and carrying it around
Neither heater needs an installer, a gas line or an outlet. You screw in a cylinder or connect the hose, push the knob and light it with the piezo igniter.
The Portable Buddy weighs 7.1 lb on its listing and carries like a lunch box, which suits a heater you move from the bench to the car to a cold corner. The Big Buddy is bulkier at 13.01 lb on the listing, or 17.1 lb by Mr. Heater’s figure, and tends to stay put.
Both may shut off above 7,000 ft, where thin air trips the low-oxygen sensor. Some owners of each report pilot trouble or a heater that stays lit only minutes.
Round goes to the Portable Buddy, lighter and easier to carry.
Fresh air, CO and fire safety
Both burn propane in the open garage air, so the carbon dioxide and water vapor stay inside, with the chance of some carbon monoxide. A 9 sq in fresh-air opening is what the Portable Buddy manual wants, and the Big Buddy’s manual wants 18 sq in, one opening up high and one down low.
That ODS reacts to falling oxygen and is blind to carbon monoxide. Keep a battery CO alarm on the wall, open the vents the manual asks for, and read how much fresh air a garage heater needs.
Both want the same clearances, with 30 in of space above, 2 ft in front and 6 in to each side. Keep them well away from the car and from rags or fuel cans, and never light one when gasoline, solvent or paint vapor hangs in the garage.
Round goes to neither, a draw, since the smaller heater asks for less air because it makes less heat.
Comfort and controls
Neither has a thermostat. The Portable Buddy has two settings, 4,000 and 9,000 BTU, and the Big Buddy adds an 18,000 BTU step on top. That third step earns its keep on bitter mornings.
Both run quietly apart from the burner hiss, since the current Big Buddy “NF” model has no fan, so there is nothing to plug in.
Round goes to the Big Buddy, for the extra step of heat.
Price and value
The Portable Buddy sits in the $ band, under $150, and is one of the most-reviewed indoor propane heaters on Amazon. The Big Buddy sits in the $$ band, between $150 and $300, so you pay roughly twice as much for twice the heat.
The listing gives the Big Buddy a 3-year limited warranty and the Portable Buddy a 1-year one, while Mr. Heater’s own page says 3 years for the small one too. Check the listing when you order.
Round goes to the Portable Buddy on price, the Big Buddy on warranty.
The Portable Buddy’s catch is size, since 9,000 BTU warms you at a bench rather than a whole cold bay, and a few owners mention pilot trouble. The Big Buddy’s catch is cylinders that empty within hours, plus owner reports of heaters that go out after a few minutes.
One bench, or the whole bay
Choose the Portable Buddy if you work at one bench in a small garage and want heat aimed at you for the least money. Take the Big Buddy for a two-car garage, feed it from a 20 lb tank outside, and keep a CO alarm on the wall with either one.