Mr. Heater Big Maxx, a permanent garage heater
The Big Maxx MHU50 is the heater to step up to once a garage is heated all winter, because it is the only one of the five with a flue. It is also the most expensive and the most work to put up. We did not install one, so this review weighs Mr. Heater’s listing and manual against what owners report.
Best permanent heater
Our verdict
The Big Maxx is the upgrade if you use your garage most of the winter and want heat that behaves like a furnace. Its flue sends carbon monoxide and water vapor outside, and a wall thermostat runs it while it stays out of the way on the ceiling. It is the priciest of the five and wants a qualified installer, the propane conversion, a gas line from a large tank, a vent and a 120 V circuit. Most garages, and every renter, are better served by our top pick, the Big Buddy.
Strengths
- Vented, so CO and water vapor leave through a flue
- About 40,000 BTU/h of output, enough for most two-car garages
- Runs on a standard 24 V or Wi-Fi wall thermostat
- High-temperature shut-off and flame-sensor gas shut-off
- Hangs on the ceiling, off the floor and away from fuel cans
Weaknesses
- Highest price band of the five, before installation
- Needs a pro install, a flue, a gas line and a 120 V circuit
- Ships set for natural gas, the LP conversion is part of the install
- Needs a ceiling of at least 10 ft
- Some owners report shipping damage, and noise reports are mixed
Buy it if
you own the garage, use it on most winter days and can pay for a flue, a gas line and a licensed installer.
Skip it if
you rent, your ceiling is under 10 ft or you only need warmth on a few cold Saturdays.
Specs: Mr. Heater Big Maxx 50,000 BTU
| Type | Vented, ceiling-mounted forced-air unit heater (Category I vent per the manual) |
|---|---|
| Heat output | 50,000 BTU/h input, 40,000 BTU/h output, 80% efficiency (manual) |
| Rated area | Up to 1,667 sq ft, about a 3-car garage (listing) |
| Fuel | Ships set for natural gas; LP (propane) conversion kit in the box, fitted during installation |
| Power | 120 V, 2.3 A for the blower and controls (manual) |
| Controls | Wall thermostat, standard 24 V or Wi-Fi (sold separately) |
| Safety | High-temperature shut-off, flame-sensor gas shut-off |
| Mounting | Ceiling; minimum 10 ft ceiling, bottom of the heater 8 ft above the floor |
| Venting | 4 in vent connector, vertical through the roof or horizontal through a wall (manual) |
| Install | By a qualified installer or the gas supplier (manual) |
| Size and weight | 24 × 25.5 × 13 in, 60.3 lb |
| Model | MHU50, part F260550 |
Data from the Amazon.com listing and, where marked, from the maker’s manual. Price band $$$: over $300. Only the price Amazon shows at checkout counts.
40,000 BTU of output for a two- or three-car garage
Mr. Heater rates the MHU50 at 50,000 BTU/h of input, and the manual gives 40,000 BTU/h of output at 80% efficiency. The listing says it heats up to 1,667 sq ft, which it describes as about a three-car garage.
Treat that area as the top of the range. One rough rule multiplies the garage’s volume by the lift you want in degrees, then by 0.133. Lifting an insulated 24-by-24 two-car garage, 9 ft to the ceiling, by 40 °F comes to roughly 27,600 BTU/h.
Without insulation the load is often 1.5 times higher, near 41,000 BTU/h, which lands right on the Big Maxx’s output. Our guide to how many BTUs a garage needs runs that sum for your own walls and ceiling.
For larger shops the same family comes as an 80,000 BTU model rated to 2,667 sq ft and a 125,000 BTU model rated to 4,167 sq ft. In most two-car garages the 50 is the sensible size, and a thermostat keeps a little headroom from turning into waste.
Why a flue matters in a garage
The flue is the whole point of this heater. The manual lists the Big Maxx as a Category I vented appliance, so its exhaust, carbon monoxide included, leaves through a 4 in vent connector instead of mixing with the air you breathe.
The water leaves with it. Burning propane makes about 1.6 lb of water per lb of fuel, and at full fire the MHU50 burns roughly 2.3 lb of propane an hour by our arithmetic, so close to 4 lb of water an hour goes up the vent.
Every unvented heater on our list leaves that water in the garage, and that is where wet floors and rusty tools come from. Our guide to damp floors and rust from a heater explains the chemistry, and vented or vent-free weighs the two designs side by side.
A flue is no excuse to skip the CO alarm. The burner draws its combustion air from the garage, and a blocked or badly joined vent can spill exhaust, so hang a battery CO alarm and have the vent and heater inspected once a year by a qualified service agency, as the manual asks.
What the installation involves
This is where the cost climbs well past the box. The heater leaves the factory on natural gas, with the parts to convert it to propane packed in the carton. The manual makes that conversion part of the installation and hands it to a pro, meaning a qualified installer, service agency or your gas company.
Beyond the conversion, the job needs a gas line from a large outdoor tank, a 120 V circuit for the blower (2.3 A per the manual) and a vent run. The vent rises through the roof or exits a side wall, with at least 3 ft of horizontal run and no shared vent.
The mounting rules are strict. The listing wants 10 ft of ceiling as a minimum, with the bottom of the heater 8 ft above the floor, and the manual keeps burners and ignition at least 18 in up because gasoline vapor is heavier than air and pools low.
The manual’s clearance table reads 18 in at the rear and on the access-panel side, 1 in on top and at each side, and 6 in between single-wall vent pipe and anything combustible. Hang it where a car or an open hood cannot reach it, and check local codes and permits before you order.
Our guide to installing a propane unit heater walks through each step and the questions to ask an installer. If your garage has an 8 ft ceiling, a landlord’s roof or no route for a vent, the Big Maxx is the wrong heater however good it is.
Fuel use and the tank behind it
At its full 50,000 BTU/h input, the MHU50 would empty a 20 lb tank in about 8.6 hours and burns a little over half a gallon an hour. That is arithmetic at full fire, and a thermostat cycles the burner, so your use depends on insulation and weather.
A grill tank is not how you feed a unit heater. Plan on a larger tank set outside by your propane supplier and piped in by a licensed installer, which also holds vapor pressure up in a cold snap when a small tank would frost and sag.
That setup costs more up front than any portable, and the tank terms depend on your supplier. Our propane tank guide compares the sizes and what each one can keep burning.
Thermostat control and comfort
The Big Maxx works with a standard 24 V wall thermostat or a Wi-Fi model, both sold separately, and the listing gives a maximum setting of 120 °F. Set a working temperature once and it cycles by itself, with no knob to babysit.
Being a forced-air heater, it warms the air rather than the person in front of it. Warm air gathers under the ceiling, so a garage takes a while to feel warm from cold, then stays even, and a ceiling fan on low pushes the heat back down.
Owners split on noise. Some describe it as quiet and others find the blower loud, which matters more in a workshop where you spend whole afternoons than in a garage you mainly park in.
Safety devices and cold weather
The listing names two safeguards, a shut-off that trips on overheating and a flame sensor that closes the gas valve if the flame goes out. The manual adds the standard unit-heater rule, keep it out of any garage whose air carries gasoline vapor, solvents, paint thinner or dust.
Frost barely touches the heater itself, since it hangs inside the garage. The weak link is the fuel supply, and a big tank outside on a properly sized line is what keeps it firing through a January night.
What owners report
Owners report that the Big Maxx performs well in two-car garages and heats quickly, and several describe the install as easy. Read that with care, because those owners tend to be comfortable with gas, electrical and vent work already.
Opinions on noise and value are mixed, and some owners report units arriving damaged or durability problems later. Inspect the carton and the cabinet on delivery, before your installer starts, so a dented heater goes back while a return is still simple.
Against the Big Buddy, the Blue Flame and other unit heaters
The Big Buddy portable, our top pick for most garages, costs far less, needs no installer and moves with you, but it is an unvented radiant heater rated to about 450 sq ft. Our Big Maxx or Big Buddy guide works out which one your garage and your winter call for.
The Blue Flame 30,000 BTU wall heater also runs on a thermostat, with no flue and no power. That saves money and work but leaves all its exhaust and moisture in the garage, as our Big Maxx or Blue Flame page shows.
Reznor and Modine build unit heaters too, usually sold through heating contractors rather than on Amazon. Compare the Big Maxx with the rest on its homepage card or in our full shortlist of the best propane garage heater picks.
When the garage needs heat all winter
If you heat your garage most of the winter and can fit a flue, a gas line and a 120 V circuit, the Big Maxx is the permanent heater we would choose. Budget for a pro install and the propane conversion, and you get thermostat heat without wet walls or a cracked door.