When the heater won’t stay lit, seven fixes

A heater that lights, burns for a minute or a quarter of an hour and then goes out is rarely broken. Most of the time a safety device is doing its job, and these seven fixes, in order, find which one and why.

Why heaters go out on purpose

Portable and vent-free propane heaters are built to shut off when something is wrong. In a pilot-lit heater, a thermocouple holds the gas valve open only while the pilot heats it, and an oxygen depletion sensor closes it when the air runs short.

A tip-over switch cuts the gas if the heater falls. So when the flame dies, ask first which guard tripped, and work through the fixes below from the simplest check to the rarest.

Owners of both Buddy heaters report pilot trouble now and then, and some say a Big Buddy stays lit only minutes. Run the list before you decide the heater is faulty.

1. Light it the way the manual says

Most pilot-lit heaters ask you to hold the control knob in after the pilot catches, so the thermocouple has time to heat. Let go too soon and the pilot dies the moment you release it.

Follow your manual’s lighting steps and timing, and on a cold morning hold a little longer. A new tank or hose can also leave air in the line, and the pilot may need a few tries to clear it.

2. Give it more fresh air

If the heater runs for a while and then goes out, the ODS is the first suspect. It shuts the heater down when oxygen in the garage drops, which happens in a closed space with too little fresh air.

Open the vents your manual lists, which means 18 sq in high and low for the Big Buddy and 9 sq in for the Portable Buddy. The ventilation guide on fresh air for a garage heater covers placement.

A heater whose ODS trips over and over is warning you. Never bypass the sensor, and keep a battery CO alarm in the garage, as the guide to carbon monoxide in a garage explains.

3. Check the tank and the cold

A cold or nearly empty tank can deliver too little gas to hold the flame. Both Buddy manuals warn that run times shrink once the air falls under 20 °F, and one 1 lb cylinder on a Big Buddy is meant for low and medium only.

Try a full 20 lb tank kept outside on a Buddy hose, which Mr. Heater recommends in the cold. The guide to why propane fades in a freezing garage explains the pressure drop.

4. Inspect the hose, regulator and filter

A remote tank connects through a Buddy hose, and the manuals say which hoses need the F273699 fuel filter. The F273701 and F273702 hoses use it, while the 10 ft F273704 hose has no filter.

A kinked hose or a clogged filter starves the burner in the same way as a cold tank. Leak-check every new connection with soapy water, and see the guide to feeding a garage heater for each setup.

Never refill a disposable 1 lb cylinder or buy a refill adapter for one. PHMSA warns against refilling them, and a fresh cylinder costs little next to the risk.

5. Set it level and out of drafts

The tip-over switch on the Buddy heaters cuts the gas when the heater tilts. A sloped slab or a wobbly perch on a toolbox may be enough to trip it without a fall.

Drafts are the other enemy of a small pilot. A gust from a raised door or a fan aimed across the heater can push the pilot flame off the thermocouple, so turn the heater out of the draft without blocking the fresh-air openings.

Keep the Buddy clearances while you move it, with 30 in of space overhead, 24 in ahead of the burner and 6 in to either side. That keeps the heater clear of the car, the cans and the rags.

6. Clean the pilot assembly

Dust and spider webs collect in the pilot and ODS assembly over a summer in the garage. A partly blocked pilot burns weak and lazy, and a weak pilot cannot keep the thermocouple hot.

Clean it as your manual describes, with the heater cold and the gas off, and avoid bending the pilot tube or the thermocouple. If the manual calls for a new pilot assembly, use the maker’s part.

In a woodshop, sawdust is a double problem. It clogs the pilot, and no heater here may run while dust is in the air.

7. Check the altitude and the model’s limits

Thin air leaves less oxygen, and an ODS reads that as a warning. The Buddy manuals say the heaters may shut off above 7,000 ft, and Mr. Heater puts the Blue Flame’s maximum at 4,500 ft.

Above those heights the shutdowns are by design rather than a fault. Ask the maker about a heater rated for your elevation instead of fighting the sensor.

Fixed and forced-air heaters

The Blue Flame lights with a battery spark, so a flat battery is the first thing to change if it will not light. Because it runs on a fixed gas line, anything beyond the battery and the fresh air is a job for the installer or the gas supplier.

The 85,000 BTU torpedo has a high-temperature limit that shuts it down if it overheats, and its fan needs power. Check that nothing blocks the air inlet or the outlet, and that it is plugged into a grounded outlet as the manual requires.

The Big Maxx has a flame-sensor gas shut-off and a high-temperature shut-off. If it keeps shutting down, call the qualified service agency that inspects it each year rather than opening the burner yourself.

If you smell gas, close the tank valve, leave the garage and air it out before you try anything else. If the CO alarm sounds or anyone has a headache, dizziness or an upset stomach, turn the heater off, move everyone outside and call for help.

When to replace it

If the heater still dies after all seven fixes, the thermocouple, the ODS or the valve may have failed. Check the warranty first, since the Big Buddy listing shows a 3-year limited warranty.

The Portable Buddy shows 1 year on its listing and 3 years on the Mr. Heater site. The Portable Buddy review weighs its pilot reports against its low price band.

The guide to garage heater brands covers alternatives such as ThermoMate and ProCom. Our garage heater buying guide compares all five, with the comparison table and the common questions on the home page.

If you are done relighting a pilot

The Big Maxx runs on a wall thermostat with a flame-sensor gas shut-off, and its flue carries the exhaust outside, so it does not depend on an oxygen sensor. It sits in the top price band and needs a qualified installer, a fair trade if the garage is heated most days.

Questions and answers

More questions about a propane heater that keeps going out

Why does my Mr. Heater Buddy shut off after a few minutes?

The likely causes are the low-oxygen sensor reacting to too little fresh air, a cold or low tank, and a draft on the pilot. Open the vents the manual asks for and try a full 20 lb tank kept outside.

How long should I hold the knob when lighting the pilot?

As long as your manual says. The knob holds the gas on while the thermocouple heats, and letting go too early is a common reason the pilot goes out at once.

Can altitude stop a propane heater staying lit?

Yes. The Buddy manuals say the heaters may shut off above 7,000 ft, and Mr. Heater puts the Blue Flame’s limit at 4,500 ft, because thinner air can trip the oxygen sensor.

Is it safe to bypass the ODS or the thermocouple?

No. Both are safety devices. A heater that keeps tripping its ODS is short of fresh air, and the fix is more ventilation and a battery CO alarm, never a bypass.

When should I call a professional?

Whenever you smell gas, when a fixed heater such as the Blue Flame or a unit heater keeps failing, or when the seven fixes do not help. Fixed gas lines and their heaters belong to a qualified installer or the gas supplier.