Blue Flame or Big Buddy heater, fixed or portable

Both are vent-free Mr. Heater heaters with a low-oxygen shut-off, and both sit in the $$ band. The Blue Flame hangs on the wall with a thermostat and a gas line, while the Big Buddy stands on the floor and runs from cylinders or a hose.

The Blue Flame for a garage you keep warm, the Big Buddy for one you visit

If you heat an insulated two-car garage most evenings and want it to hold a set temperature, the Blue Flame 30,000 BTU wall heater fits that job. It has a built-in thermostat, needs no electricity and runs from a fixed propane line.

The Big Buddy suits a renter, a garage you use on Saturdays, or anyone who cannot run a gas line. It sits on the floor, runs on cylinders or a 20 lb tank kept outside, and goes back on the shelf in spring.

Both feature in our propane garage heater comparison, the wall unit as the wall heater pick and the Buddy as our top pick. The Buddy also meets its smaller sibling, and the Blue Flame meets the vented Big Maxx.

Blue Flame and Big Buddy side by side

Numbers come from the Amazon.com listings and, where we say so, from Mr. Heater. The Blue Flame here is the dual-fuel model, because the propane-only sibling was unavailable on Amazon.com when we read the listings.

FeatureBlue Flame 30,000 BTU (MHVFDF30BFT)Big Buddy (MH18B)
TypeVent-free blue flame convection heater, wall mountPortable radiant heater, certified for indoor use
Heat output30,000 BTU/h18,000 BTU/h at the top, with 9,000 and 4,000 below
Rated areaUp to 1,000 sq ft (listing)Up to about 450 sq ft
Fuel and tankLP or natural gas, hard-piped from a tank outdoorsDisposable 1 lb cylinders, or an outdoor 20 lb tank on a Buddy hose
Run timeAbout 14 h per 20 lb (arithmetic); usually piped from a bigger tank24–108 h per 20 lb (manual)
Power neededNone, battery spark ignitionNone, piezo igniter
ThermostatBuilt in, adjustableNone, three settings
Venting and fresh airNo flue; Mr. Heater asks for outside ventilation airNone; the manual asks for 18 sq in openings
Safety devicesODS pilotODS plus a tip-over switch
InstallWall mount; gas line by a licensed installerNone
Weight26.1 lbAbout 13 lb on the listing (Mr. Heater says 17.1 lb)
Price band$$, the middle band$$, the middle band
WarrantyLimited, 1 year3-year limited (listing)

Heat and garage size

The Blue Flame puts out 30,000 BTU, which by the usual rule of thumb lifts an insulated 24 by 24 ft garage with a 9 ft ceiling about 40 °F. That example needs near 27,600 BTU/h, so the wall heater has a little in hand and the Buddy falls well short.

Mr. Heater rates the Blue Flame for up to 1,000 sq ft and the Big Buddy for about 450 sq ft. Both figures assume mild weather and insulation, and a bare-stud garage often needs half again as much, which our BTU sizing guide explains.

They also heat in different ways. The Blue Flame warms the air by convection, so the whole garage comes up slowly and evenly, with warmth pooling under the ceiling. The Buddy’s glowing face warms you and the bench first.

Two side views of a garage: a radiant heater warming a person and workbench in front of it, and a forced-air heater moving warm air that rises and spreads under the ceiling
A radiant Buddy warms you and the bench it faces within minutes. Forced-air and convection heaters warm the air itself, which heats the whole garage but rises first, so the ceiling warms before your feet do.

Round goes to the Blue Flame, with enough heat for the whole garage.

Fuel and running

The Big Buddy runs from one or two 1 lb cylinders, or from a 20 lb tank outside on a Buddy hose, and its manual gives 24 to 108 hours per 20 lb. That suits occasional use with no plumbing at all.

The Blue Flame needs a fixed supply. At 30,000 BTU, a 20 lb tank holding about 432,000 BTU lasts roughly 14 hours by arithmetic, so it is normally piped from a larger outdoor tank, with the line run to code from outside.

Cold affects both. Propane boils at about −44 °F, yet its vapor pressure falls as a tank chills, and small tanks fade under steady draw. The big tank behind a wall heater keeps up better than a 20 lb cylinder on a frosty morning.

Round goes to the Big Buddy for occasional use, the Blue Flame for a heater that runs all winter.

Install and setup

The Buddy comes out of the box ready to light. You attach a cylinder, push the knob and press the igniter, and there is nothing to mount, pipe or permit.

The Blue Flame hangs on the wall with the hardware in the box, but its gas line should be run by a licensed gas fitter or the company that fills your tank, under a permit if your town asks for one. Owners call it easy to install, meaning the mounting, not the gas work.

Check your local code before you buy. Massachusetts and Canada restrict unvented propane heaters indoors, Mr. Heater flags this model as not for California, and its maximum elevation is 4,500 ft. Our guide to vented and vent-free heaters explains why the rules differ.

Round goes to the Big Buddy, which needs no install at all.

Air quality and safety

Neither has a flue. Each pound of fuel turns into roughly 1.6 lb of moisture that stays put, along with carbon dioxide and possibly some carbon monoxide. At 30,000 BTU the Blue Flame burns more fuel per hour, so it adds more of each.

Mr. Heater says the Blue Flame needs outside air, and its ODS shuts it down without enough. Under the National Fuel Gas Code, less than 50 cu ft of room for each 1,000 BTU/h counts as a confined space, so this heater wants 1,500 cu ft or more without added outdoor air.

The Big Buddy needs 18 sq in of opening, high and low. With either one, mount a battery CO alarm, keep gasoline and solvent fumes out, and read our fresh-air guide for garage heaters before the first cold night.

Round goes to the Big Buddy, for a smaller exhaust load and a tip-over switch.

Comfort and controls

The built-in thermostat is the Blue Flame’s strongest card, and owners describe it as consistent. Set it once and the burner cycles to hold the garage near that point, without you walking over to turn a knob.

The Big Buddy has three fixed settings and no thermostat. That suits a two-hour project, but you will turn it down by hand as the garage warms. For the Blue Flame, an optional blower kit (F299201) spreads its warm air and is sold separately.

Round goes to the Blue Flame, for a thermostat that holds the temperature.

Price and value

Both sit in the $$ band, between $150 and $300, so the sticker rarely decides it. On top of the heater, the Blue Flame needs a gas line, an installer and possibly a bigger tank, while the Big Buddy adds only a hose and a filter.

The Big Buddy carries a 3-year limited warranty on its listing, the Blue Flame a 1-year one. Owners of both call them good value for the heat they give.

Round goes to the Big Buddy, cheaper to get running.

The Blue Flame’s catch is that it is still vent-free, so a thermostat that runs it for hours also fills the garage with moisture and exhaust, and it needs a gas line and a code check. The Big Buddy’s catch is cylinders that empty in hours and no thermostat.

A fixture or a visitor

If you heat the garage most evenings and can run a gas line, the Blue Flame keeps a steady temperature from the wall. For weekend projects, a rental or no gas work, take the Big Buddy, and keep a CO alarm up with either one.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Blue Flame and the Big Buddy

Can I put a vent-free Blue Flame heater in my garage?

Often, but check your local code first. Massachusetts and Canada restrict unvented propane heaters indoors, Mr. Heater says the model is not for California, and it works up to 4,500 ft. The garage also needs outside ventilation air.

Does the Blue Flame need electricity?

No. It lights with a battery-operated spark igniter, and the battery is included. The thermostat is built in, so the heater keeps working without an outlet nearby.

Can a Big Buddy heat my garage all day?

On a 20 lb tank outside, the manual gives 24 to 108 hours. Keep the fresh-air openings the manual asks for, run a battery CO alarm, and never leave it burning while you sleep in the garage.

Which one makes more moisture in the garage?

The Blue Flame, because it burns more propane per hour. Burning one pound of fuel releases around 1.6 lb of moisture, which ends up on cold tools, windows and the floor unless fresh air carries it out.

Do I need a professional to install the Blue Flame?

For the gas line, yes. Leave the run from the outside tank to a licensed pro or your propane company, and pull a permit if your town requires one. Hanging the heater itself is simpler, and owners call it easy.