Mr. Heater Big Buddy, the garage heater we would buy
The Big Buddy is our top pick because most garage owners can use it tomorrow, with no installer, no flue and no wiring. It is certified for indoor use, and it still asks for fresh air and a CO alarm. We did not run one ourselves, so this review sets the listing and manual against what owners report.
Our top pick
Our verdict
The Big Buddy is the heater we would buy first for most garages, and the easy choice if you rent, cannot fit a flue or work in the garage a few days a week. It throws 18,000 BTU of radiant heat at you and your bench, runs on a 20 lb tank kept outside and needs nothing installed. It is unvented, so it needs its vent openings and a CO alarm, it has no thermostat, and some owners report it shutting off after a few minutes. In a cold uninsulated two-car garage it warms your corner, not the whole room.
Strengths
- Certified for indoor use, with an ODS and a tip-over switch
- Three settings from 4,000 to 18,000 BTU/h
- 24 to 108 hours on a 20 lb tank kept outside (manual)
- No power, no install, no fan noise
- 3-year limited warranty on the listing
Weaknesses
- Unvented, so moisture and exhaust stay in the garage
- Needs 18 sq in vent openings high and low
- No thermostat, you adjust it by hand
- Some owners report it dying after about 15 minutes
- Not for Massachusetts, Canada or a California dwelling
Buy it if
you want indoor-certified heat without an installer, in a one-car or insulated garage or one bay of a two-car garage.
Skip it if
you want to keep a whole uninsulated two-car garage warm all day, or you will not open vents and hang a CO alarm.
Specs: Mr. Heater Big Buddy
| Type | Portable radiant propane heater, certified for indoor use |
|---|---|
| Heat output | 4,000, 9,000 or 18,000 BTU/h |
| Rated area | Up to about 450 sq ft |
| Fuel | One or two 1 lb cylinders, or a 20 lb tank outside via a Buddy hose (sold separately) |
| Run time | 24 to 108 hours on a 20 lb tank; 1.5 to 6 hours on one 1 lb cylinder (manual) |
| Power | None (current “NF” model has no fan) |
| Safety | Low-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch |
| Vent needed | 18 sq in fresh-air opening at ceiling and floor (manual) |
| Ignition | Piezo |
| Weight | 13.01 lb on the listing; Mr. Heater gives 17.1 lb |
| Warranty | 3-year limited (listing) |
| Model | MH18B |
Data from the Amazon.com listing and, where marked, from the maker’s manual. Price band $$: $150 to $300. Only the price Amazon shows at checkout counts.
18,000 BTU of radiant heat, and the garage it suits
The Big Buddy MH18B has three settings, from 4,000 BTU/h on low to 18,000 on high with 9,000 in the middle. The listing says it heats up to about 450 sq ft, which suits a one-car garage or a single bay of a larger one.
By a common sizing rule, an insulated two-car garage of about 5,200 cu ft needs nearer 27,600 BTU/h to warm up by 40 °F. Eighteen thousand falls well short, so in a large garage you feel the Big Buddy where you stand rather than across the room.
Radiant heat warms what it faces. Point it at the bench and you feel it within minutes while the air is still cool, which is exactly why a Buddy works as spot heat in a garage you never fully close up.
The “NF” in the name means no fan. Mr. Heater removed the fan from current units, so the Big Buddy needs no batteries and makes no fan noise, but it also does nothing to spread warm air around the garage.
Cylinders, a 20 lb tank and run time
On a 20 lb tank the manual quotes between 24 and 108 hours. A lone 1 lb cylinder gives 1.5 to 6, two of them 3 to 12, and with just one cylinder fitted it runs on low or medium only.
For a garage the 20 lb tank is the sensible fuel, and the manual says it must never come indoors. Feed the heater from a tank outside with a Buddy hose, either the 10 ft F273704 or the F273701 and F273702 hoses with the F273699 fuel filter.
Disposable 1 lb cylinders cost far more per hour of heat and must never be refilled, as PHMSA warns. Our guide to 1 lb, 20 lb and 100 lb tanks compares what each size costs you in hassle and hours.
Fresh air, the ODS and carbon monoxide
Indoor certification does not make the Big Buddy vented. Its exhaust stays in the garage, water vapor included, roughly 1.3 lb an hour on high by our arithmetic, and that moisture ends up on cold windows and tools.
The manual calls for two openings of 18 sq in each, roughly 4.25 in square, one up near the ceiling and one down by the floor. A door left open at the bottom alone does not do it, because stale air needs a way out up high.
The low-oxygen shutoff turns the heater off when oxygen runs low, and a tip-over switch kills it if it falls. Neither one senses carbon monoxide, so a battery CO alarm belongs in the garage, plus another in the house if the garage is attached.
Give it 30 in of headroom, 2 ft of open space in front and 6 in on either side, well away from the car, rags and cardboard. Any whiff of gasoline, solvent or paint means the heater goes off, and nobody sleeps in a garage where it is lit.
Setup and controls
Setup means threading on a cylinder or connecting the hose, lighting it with the piezo igniter and picking a setting. Leak-check a new hose joint with soapy water the first time, and shut the tank valve when you finish.
There is no thermostat, so you turn it up or down by hand as the garage warms. The listing gives 13.01 lb and Mr. Heater gives 17.1 lb, light enough either way to carry from the bench to the car.
The listing carries a 3-year limited warranty, longer than the 1-year terms on most heaters here. Keep the receipt, since pilot and ODS faults are the most common owner complaint.
How it copes with freezing weather
Under 20 °F, the manual says, run times get shorter, and it recommends a 20 lb tank for cold weather. A small cylinder chills as it empties and loses pressure, which our cold-weather propane guide covers in detail.
A 20 lb tank also helps on the first cold morning, when you most want high. A single 1 lb cylinder runs low or medium only, so an outdoor tank on a hose is the setup that gives you all three settings.
Altitude is less of a worry for most readers. The manual says it may shut off above 7,000 ft, and owners report it working well at high elevation.
What owners report
Owners say it raises a room by about 20 °F in 30 minutes, works indoors and outdoors, and many use it through the winter in garages and workshops. Value for money comes up often.
The complaint that keeps returning is a heater that stays lit for only a few minutes or dies after about 15, usually traced to the pilot or the ODS. Fresh air, a clean pilot and a filtered hose are the first things to check, and the won’t-stay-lit checklist works through them one at a time.
Check the rules where you live. The Big Buddy is not for Massachusetts or Canada, and its manual says it is not for use in a dwelling home in California.
Against the Big Maxx, the Portable Buddy and the Blue Flame
The Big Maxx unit heater is the upgrade if you end up heating the garage all winter and can fit a flue. Our unit heater or Big Buddy guide sets out where each of the two makes sense.
The Portable Buddy gives half the output in the $ band, enough for one person at a bench, and Portable Buddy or Big Buddy puts them side by side. The Blue Flame wall heater adds a thermostat, as our fixed or portable comparison explains.
ThermoMate and others sell plaque heaters with far fewer owner reports. See the Big Buddy’s homepage card or the rest of our propane garage heater comparison.
Our top pick for most garages
For warmth where you stand with no installer, no outlet and an indoor rating, the Big Buddy is the heater to get first. Run it from a 20 lb tank outside, give it its vent openings and hang a CO alarm before the first cold morning.