A cheap garage heater under $150, and what it gives up

Only one heater in our lineup sits in the under-$150 band, and it is a good one for the right job. This page shows what that low price leaves out, how far 9,000 BTU stretches in a garage, and when stepping up a band saves you money over a winter.

What “cheap” buys in a propane garage heater

We never print prices, only bands. Under $150 is the $ band and $150 to $300 is $$, while anything over $300 counts as $$$.

Just one of the five heaters in our propane garage heater comparison lands in the $ band, the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy. Three sit in the $$ band, and the ceiling-hung Big Maxx is the only one above $300.

A cheap heater burns propane the same way a costly one does. The savings come out of heat output, run time per cylinder and the warranty, and a few of those you only notice on a cold Saturday.

The one heater in the $ band

The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy is a 9,000 BTU radiant heater with two settings, 4,000 and 9,000 BTU/h. The listing rates it for about 225 sq ft and certifies it for indoor and outdoor use.

Heat output
4,000 or 9,000 BTU/h, radiant
Rated area
Up to about 225 sq ft (listing)
Fuel
One 1 lb cylinder, or a 20 lb tank kept outside via a Buddy hose
Run time
5.4 h on low, 2.4 h on high per 1 lb cylinder (listing)
Safety
Low-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch, piezo ignition
Fresh air
9 sq in vent area, about 3 × 3 in (manual)

It is our budget spot heat pick, and it tops its Amazon category for indoor propane space heaters. Our Portable Buddy review goes through the manual and the owner reports in full.

What the low price gives up

Nothing on the Portable Buddy is unsafe for the price. The compromises sit in how much it does and how long it keeps doing it.

  • Heat output, at 9,000 BTU/h on high, half of what the Big Buddy gives
  • Fuel economy on small bottles, since a 1 lb cylinder lasts about 2.4 hours on high
  • Settings, with two steps instead of three
  • Warranty, 1-year limited on the Amazon listing (the Mr. Heater site says 3 years)
  • Consistency, as some owners report units that stop working after a few uses
  • A steady pilot, with pilot flame problems among the complaints

Plenty of owners still call it good value and easy to light. Many use it for camping too, which tells you what it does best, warming the space right around you.

How far 9,000 BTU goes in a garage

A one-car garage is typically 240 to 300 sq ft, already past the Portable Buddy’s 225 sq ft rating. Makers’ area figures assume mild weather and insulation, so treat them as the top of the range.

One common rule of thumb takes the volume in cubic feet, times the rise in °F you want, times 0.133 for an insulated space. A 12 × 22 ft garage with a 9 ft ceiling and a 30 °F rise works out near 9,500 BTU/h, our arithmetic.

Uninsulated, the same garage often needs 1.5 times that or more. Our garage heater sizing guide walks through the sums for one-, two- and three-car garages.

So the Portable Buddy is spot heat. Sit it a few feet from your bench and it warms you and the vise, while a cold two-car garage around you stays cold.

The fuel bill behind a cheap heater

One 1 lb cylinder carries about 22,100 BTU of propane. On high, that matches the listing’s 2.4 hours, and an afternoon in the shop can empty two or three of them.

A 20 lb tank holds about 432,000 BTU, roughly 48 hours at 9,000 BTU/h by arithmetic, and less in deep cold. The tank stays outside and feeds the heater through a Buddy hose, with the fuel filter the manual specifies.

Bar chart of how many hours each garage heater runs on 20 lb of propane, from the high to the low setting
Hours per 20 lb of propane (about 432,000 BTU). The Big Buddy figures come from Mr. Heater’s manual, the others are arithmetic from the rated input or fuel rate. Cold tanks give less, and the fixed heaters normally run from a much bigger tank.

Never refill the disposable 1 lb cylinders, whatever an adapter listing promises. The federal pipeline and hazmat agency, PHMSA, warns against refilling them, because they are not built for it.

Fresh air comes free

A cheap heater is unvented like the dearer portables. It burns the garage’s oxygen and leaves carbon dioxide, water vapor and possibly carbon monoxide in the air you breathe.

The Portable Buddy manual asks for a 9 sq in vent area, and the ODS shuts it off if oxygen runs low. That sensor watches oxygen, not CO, so a battery CO alarm on the wall is part of the purchase.

Our guide to fresh air for a garage heater shows where to make the openings. Never run it with gasoline, solvent or paint fumes in the air, and never sleep in the garage with it lit.

When the Big Buddy pays you back

HeaterTypeHeat outputRated areaPrice band
Portable BuddyPortable radiant4,000–9,000 BTU/hAbout 225 sq ft$
Big BuddyPortable radiant4,000–18,000 BTU/hAbout 450 sq ft$$
Blue Flame 30,000 BTUVent-free wall30,000 BTU/hUp to 1,000 sq ft$$
Forced air 85,000 BTUTorpedo50,000–85,000 BTU/hUp to 2,125 sq ft$$
Big Maxx 50,000 BTUVented unit heater50,000 BTU/h inputUp to 1,667 sq ft$$$

The full comparison table on the homepage adds fuel, power and venting for all five.

The Mr. Heater Big Buddy is the natural step up. It doubles the output to 18,000 BTU/h, adds a third setting, accepts a pair of small cylinders or a hose to a 20 lb tank, and carries a 3-year limited warranty on its listing.

If you work in a two-car garage, or spend whole weekends out there, that extra heat matters more than the band. The Big Buddy review covers its 18 sq in vent rule and the pilot complaints some owners raise.

An electric garage heater is a different route with no combustion at all. It needs a circuit sized for it, and it is outside what this site compares.

Cheap traps to skip

Skip any cheap torpedo heater as a way to keep a closed garage warm. Forced-air heaters throw every bit of their exhaust into the room and want large fresh-air openings, so they suit short, attended warm-ups in a ventilated shop.

Skip bringing the 20 lb tank inside to save on hose length. The Buddy manuals say a tank that size stays outdoors, and spare cylinders belong outside too, upright and away from heat.

Skip unbranded heaters with no ODS or tip-over switch mentioned on the listing. And never warm up the car or run a generator in the garage, even with the door open.

A cheap heater is only as safe as the garage you run it in. Give it the vent area its manual asks for, keep 30 in above it and 24 in in front of it clear, and park it away from the car, rags and fuel cans.

Fit a battery CO alarm before the first cold morning, and switch the heater off whenever you leave the garage.

Our pick if you want to spend the least

For spot heat at a bench in a one-car garage, the Portable Buddy is the under-$150 heater we would choose, with an ODS, a tip-over switch and a 20 lb tank option. Buy it expecting warmth around you, not a warm garage.

Questions and answers

More questions about cheap garage heaters

Is there a good propane garage heater under $150?

Yes, for spot heat. The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy is the one heater of our five in that band, a 9,000 BTU radiant heater rated for about 225 sq ft with an oxygen sensor and a tip-over switch.

Will a 9,000 BTU heater warm a two-car garage?

Not the whole space. A two-car garage is typically 400 to 600 sq ft, about twice the Portable Buddy’s rating. It warms you at a bench, while the Big Buddy or a fixed heater suits the larger room.

How long does a 1 lb cylinder last in a Portable Buddy?

The listing gives 5.4 hours on low and 2.4 hours on high. A 20 lb tank kept outside on a Buddy hose holds roughly 48 hours at 9,000 BTU by arithmetic, less in deep cold.

Can I refill the small 1 lb propane cylinders?

No. PHMSA warns against refilling disposable 1 lb cylinders, so skip refill adapters. Use new cylinders, or move to a 20 lb tank that stays outside and feeds the heater through a hose.

Is the Big Buddy worth the higher price band?

If you heat a two-car garage or work out there for hours, usually yes. It doubles the output to 18,000 BTU, adds a third setting and carries a 3-year limited warranty on its listing.