Big Maxx or Blue Flame, a vented or vent-free heater

Both are fixed heaters on a gas line with a thermostat, built for a garage you heat all winter. The Big Maxx sends its exhaust out through a flue, the Blue Flame keeps it in the garage, and that one difference shapes the rest.

The Big Maxx if you heat all winter, the Blue Flame if a flue is out of reach

For a garage you heat most days from fall to spring, the Big Maxx 50,000 BTU unit heater is our pick for a permanent install. It is the only heater on our list that sends CO and water vapor outside through a flue, and it runs from a wall thermostat.

The Blue Flame 30,000 BTU suits a smaller garage, a lower ceiling or a budget that cannot stretch to a flue and a pro install. It hangs on the wall, needs no power and has its own thermostat, but its exhaust stays in the room.

The Big Maxx is the permanent heater pick in our best propane garage heater roundup, and the Blue Flame is the wall heater pick. The Big Maxx also meets the portable Big Buddy, and the Blue Flame faces the 85,000 BTU torpedo.

Big Maxx and Blue Flame side by side

Figures come from the Amazon.com listings and the Big Maxx manual, which gives input and output separately. Mr. Heater sets the Big Maxx up for natural gas at the factory and packs a propane kit that the installer fits.

FeatureBig Maxx MHU50Blue Flame 30,000 BTU (MHVFDF30BFT)
TypeVented ceiling-mounted forced-air unit heaterVent-free blue flame, mounted on a wall
Heat output50,000 BTU/h input, 40,000 BTU/h output, 80% efficiency (manual)30,000 BTU/h
Rated area1,667 sq ft at most, roughly three cars (listing)1,000 sq ft at most (listing)
Fuel and tankNatural gas as shipped, LP kit included; gas line from a large tankPropane or natural gas via a permanent line from outdoors
Run timeAbout 8.6 h per 20 lb (arithmetic), so it needs a large tankAbout 14 h per 20 lb (arithmetic)
Power needed120 V, 2.3 A (manual)None, battery spark ignition
ThermostatWall thermostat, 24 V or Wi-Fi, sold separatelyBuilt in, adjustable
Venting and fresh air4 in vent, vertical or sidewall; exhaust leaves the garageNone; needs outdoor ventilation air (maker)
Safety devicesOverheat shut-off and a flame sensor that closes the gasLow-oxygen shut-off (ODS)
InstallA pro or the gas supplier; ceiling of 10 ft or moreWall mount; gas line by a licensed installer
Weight60.3 lb26.1 lb
Price band$$$ (over $300)$$ ($150 to $300)
WarrantyCheck the listing1-year limited

Heat and garage size

The Big Maxx burns 50,000 BTU and, by its manual, delivers 40,000 BTU into the garage at 80% efficiency, since some heat leaves with the flue gas. The listing puts its reach at 1,667 sq ft, and owners say two-car garages warm up fast with it.

The Blue Flame delivers all 30,000 BTU into the room, because nothing leaves through a flue, and it is rated for up to 1,000 sq ft. An insulated two-car garage with a 40 °F rise sits within reach of both, as our garage BTU guide works out.

In a bigger or uninsulated garage the picture shifts. The extra 10,000 BTU of delivered heat and the Big Maxx blower that pushes it across the bay both start to count.

Round goes to the Big Maxx, with more heat and room to grow.

Venting, moisture and CO

This is the round that decides it. For every pound of propane burned, roughly 1.6 lb of water forms, and the Big Maxx sends it up the flue along with the carbon dioxide and any CO. The garage stays drier, and no door has to stay cracked for it.

The Blue Flame keeps all of it inside. It burns about 1.4 lb of propane an hour on full, so an evening leaves several pounds of water to settle on cold tools, windows and the car. Our guide to wet floors and rusty tools explains where it goes.

Mr. Heater requires outside ventilation air for the Blue Flame, and its ODS cuts out when oxygen runs low. The ODS does not detect CO, so a battery CO alarm comes with the deal, and the vented or vent-free guide sets the two systems side by side.

A flue is no reason to skip the alarm. The Big Maxx draws its combustion air from the garage, its vent needs an inspection once a year by a qualified service agency, and a CO alarm still belongs on the wall.

Round goes to the Big Maxx, clearly.

Install and setup

The Big Maxx is a project. A qualified installer or the gas supplier converts it from natural gas to propane, runs a gas line from a large tank, and fits a 4 in vent through the roof or a sidewall, and you need a 120 V circuit. Check local codes and permits first.

The ceiling must be at least 10 ft, with the heater’s base 8 ft above the floor and out of the way of vehicles. Clearances are 1 in at the top and sides, 18 in on the access-panel side and rear, and 6 in between single-wall vent pipe and combustibles.

Our guide to installing a unit heater walks through the steps and the questions to ask the installer. The burners also sit at least 18 in above the floor, where gasoline vapor that pools low cannot reach them.

The Blue Flame mounts on a wall with the hardware in the box, and owners call it easy to install. It still needs a gas line from an outside tank, run to code by a licensed installer, and Mr. Heater limits it to 4,500 ft and rules out California.

Round goes to the Blue Flame, the simpler and cheaper install.

Comfort and controls

The Big Maxx works with a standard 24 V or Wi-Fi thermostat, sold separately, so the control can sit by the house door. Its blower spreads heat across the bay, and owners give mixed reports on how loud it is.

The Blue Flame has its thermostat built in, which owners describe as consistent, and runs without a fan unless you add the optional blower kit. Warm air rises from it and pools under the ceiling, so your feet warm last.

Round goes to the Big Maxx for control and air movement, though the Blue Flame is quieter.

Price and value

The Big Maxx sits in the $$$ band, over $300, before the installer, vent pipe, thermostat and tank. The Blue Flame sits in the $$ band, between $150 and $300, plus its gas line and installer.

Owners are mixed on the Big Maxx’s value, and a few report damaged arrivals or durability problems, so inspect it on delivery. Blue Flame owners call it good value, and over many winters the flue is what you are paying for.

Round goes to the Blue Flame on price, the Big Maxx on long-term comfort.

The Big Maxx’s catch is everything around it, a pro install, a flue, a 120 V circuit, a 10 ft ceiling and a large tank, which renters and occasional users cannot justify. The Blue Flame’s catch is the air, since its exhaust and moisture stay in the garage every hour it runs.

Out the flue or into the room

If you heat the garage all winter and own the building, mount the Big Maxx and let the flue carry the exhaust out. If a flue or a 10 ft ceiling is out of reach, the Blue Flame holds a set temperature for less, with fresh air and a CO alarm.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Big Maxx and the Blue Flame

Is a vented garage heater safer than a vent-free one?

A vented heater sends carbon monoxide and water vapor outside through its flue, so the garage air stays cleaner and drier. It still needs a correct install, a yearly vent inspection and a battery CO alarm on the wall.

Can I install the Big Maxx myself?

Mr. Heater says no. Its manual leaves the job, propane conversion included, to trained gas professionals or your propane company. Check local codes and permits before you order.

Will the Big Maxx work with my propane tank?

Only after conversion. Mr. Heater sets it up at the factory for natural gas and packs an LP kit, which the installer fits before hooking it to a line from a large propane tank.

What ceiling height does the Big Maxx need?

The listing asks for at least a 10 ft ceiling with 8 ft from the base of the heater to the floor. In a residential garage the manual also keeps the burners at least 18 in above the floor and the heater out of the way of vehicles.

Will a Blue Flame heater make my garage damp?

It can. At full output it uses about 1.4 lb of propane an hour, and each of those pounds turns into roughly 1.6 lb of moisture. Fresh air carries it out, and a vented heater avoids it.