Our top pick
Mr. Heater Big Buddy MH18B, 18,000 BTU
The Big Buddy is a radiant heater you set on the floor and aim at the bench or the car you are working on. It has three settings, 4,000, 9,000 and 18,000 BTU, and the listing rates it for about 450 sq ft.
Mr. Heater certifies it for indoor use and fits a low-oxygen shut-off (ODS) and a tip-over switch. It needs no electricity, since the current “NF” model has no fan, and a piezo button lights it.
Fuel comes from one or two disposable 1 lb cylinders or, better, a 20 lb tank that stays outdoors and feeds it through a Buddy hose. On that tank the manual quotes 24 to 108 hours, and the listing carries a 3-year limited warranty.
- Heat output
- 4,000, 9,000 or 18,000 BTU
- Rated area
- About 450 sq ft (listing)
- Fuel
- 1 lb cylinders or an outdoor 20 lb tank via hose
- Run time
- 24 to 108 h per 20 lb (manual)
- Power
- None, no fan
- Safety
- ODS and tip-over switch
- Fresh air
- 18 sq in at ceiling and floor (manual)
- Weight
- 13.01 lb listed, 17.1 lb per Mr. Heater
Your setup, step by step
No installer is involved, but the fresh air and the alarm are part of the job. Do them in this order before the first cold morning, and repeat the second half every time you light it.
Before you light it
- Make two fresh-air openings of 18 sq in, one near the ceiling and one near the floor
- Hang a battery CO alarm in the garage, and one in the house if the garage is attached
- Leave 30 in of space overhead, 2 ft in front and 6 in on each side, away from the car, rags and cans
- Stand the 20 lb tank outside, upright, and run a Buddy hose in to the heater
Then light it and stay with it
Every time you use it
- Leak-check a new hose joint with soapy water before the first run
- Light it with the piezo button and start on low or medium
- Switch it off at once if you smell gasoline, solvent or paint
- Turn it off and close the tank before you leave the garage or rest
What it has, and what it lacks
What it has
- Indoor certification, an ODS and a tip-over switch
- Three settings from 4,000 to 18,000 BTU
- No install, no outlet and no fan noise
- A day or more of heat from a 20 lb tank outside
- A 3-year limited warranty on the listing
What it lacks
- A flue, its exhaust and moisture stay in the garage
- A thermostat, you turn it up and down by hand
- Whole-room heat in a cold, uninsulated two-car bay
- A clean record, some owners say it will not stay lit
Between us, before you order
Indoor-certified does not mean vented. Its carbon dioxide, water vapor and any carbon monoxide stay in the air you breathe, so the two 18 sq in openings and a battery CO alarm are part of owning one, and nobody sleeps in the garage while it burns.
At 18,000 BTU it warms you and the bench in a cold two-car garage, not the far corner. A one-car or insulated garage can get comfortable, and if you end up heating all winter, the vented Big Maxx is the upgrade.
What owners report
Owners say it lifts a room by about 20 °F in half an hour, and many run it through the winter in garages and workshops. Good value is a theme that keeps coming up.
The recurring complaint is a heater that stays lit only a few minutes or quits after about 15, usually the pilot or the ODS. Fresh air, a full tank and a filtered hose come first, as our seven fixes explain.
Buy it if
You want heat this week without an installer, you rent or work in the garage on some days, and you will give it fresh air and a CO alarm.
Skip it if
- Heating it all winter? Step up to the Big Maxx unit heater
- Want a thermostat? Try the Blue Flame wall heater
- Need heat in minutes? Look at the 85,000 BTU torpedo
- One bench, small budget? See the Portable Buddy
Ready for warm hands this winter?
Add a 20 lb tank outside, a Buddy hose, two fresh-air openings and a battery CO alarm. With those in place, the Big Buddy is where we would start in almost any garage.