Wet floors and rust from a heater, and how to stop it

You fire up a portable heater, the garage warms, and an hour later the windows stream and the floor looks wet. The heater did not leak. It made the water, and how you vent the garage decides where that water ends up.

Where the water comes from

Propane is made of carbon and hydrogen. When it burns, the hydrogen joins oxygen and becomes water, about 1.6 lb of it for every pound of propane.

A vented heater sends that water up its flue with the rest of the exhaust. An unvented heater, whether a Buddy, a blue flame wall heater or a torpedo, leaves all of it in your garage as vapor.

Warm air holds that vapor for a while. Then it meets something cold, cools below its dew point and turns back into liquid on the surface, a process the glossary calls condensation.

How much water a heater makes

The figures below are arithmetic, using about 21,600 BTU per pound of propane and 1.6 lb of water per pound burned. A gallon of water weighs about 8.3 lb.

Heater and settingPropane per hourWater per hour
Portable Buddy, 9,000 BTUAbout 0.42 lbAbout 0.67 lb
Big Buddy, 18,000 BTUAbout 0.83 lbAbout 1.3 lb
Blue Flame, 30,000 BTUAbout 1.4 lbAbout 2.2 lb
Forced air, 85,000 BTU3.9 lb (manual)About 6.2 lb

A full 20 lb tank burned in a closed garage leaves about 32 lb of water behind, close to 4 gallons. Some of it escapes through cracks and openings, and the rest ends up on your windows, tools, car and floor.

Why it lands on your tools

Condensation forms on the coldest things in the room. In a garage that means the concrete slab, the steel of your tools and toolbox, the car body and single-pane windows.

A slab that sat at freezing all night stays cold long after the air warms. That is why a heated garage often looks wetter than an unheated one, with damp concrete under the car and beads on every wrench.

A car driven in with snow on it adds its own water as the snow melts. On a cold morning that alone can make the floor slick before the heater does anything.

Radiant heat and warm surfaces

Radiant heaters such as the Big Buddy warm what they face rather than the air. Tools on a bench in front of one warm up with you, which helps keep them above the point where water settles.

Two side views of a garage: a radiant heater warming a person and workbench in front of it, and a forced-air heater moving warm air that rises and spreads under the ceiling
A radiant Buddy warms you and the bench it faces within minutes. Forced-air and convection heaters warm the air itself, which heats the whole garage but rises first, so the ceiling warms before your feet do.

Forced-air and convection heaters warm the air first, and the heat pools high under the ceiling. The warm air holds more vapor, but the floor and the far corners stay cold, so that is where the water lands.

Neither type removes water from the garage. Only fresh air or a flue does that, which is the heart of the fix.

Six ways to a drier garage

  1. Give the heater the fresh-air openings its manual asks for, one low and one high
  2. Run a portable heater for the session you work, not around the clock
  3. Brush snow and ice off the car outside before you pull in
  4. Insulate the walls and the door, so surfaces stay warmer and need less heat
  5. Wipe and oil bare steel tools, and keep the good ones in a closed box
  6. Let the garage air out for a while after the heater goes off

Fresh air does most of the work. The guide to how much fresh air a heater needs gives the opening size for each heater, and the openings grow with the BTUs.

Bigger heater, more water

The water scales with the propane you burn, so an oversized heater on high makes the most. A torpedo puts about 6 lb of water an hour into the air, and its manual already restricts it to well-ventilated areas.

A heater sized to the garage can drop to a lower setting once the space is warm, and it burns less propane doing it. The guide to garage heater BTUs shows how to size one without overshooting.

Cold weather adds a twist. A frosted tank in a freezing garage can sag and leave you running the heater longer, which the guide to propane in the cold explains.

The fix that removes the water

A vented heater is the only one here that sends its water outside. The Big Maxx unit heater pushes its exhaust through a flue, so the vapor never meets your tools.

The guide to vented and vent-free heaters sets out the trade. A vent-free heater is cheaper to fit and needs no flue, while a vented one costs more and keeps the garage drier and the air cleaner.

Never seal up a garage to stop the drafts that seem to make it colder. Closing in an unvented heater traps its water vapor and its carbon monoxide together, so keep the openings open and a battery CO alarm on the wall.

A dehumidifier, and its limits

An electric dehumidifier pulls water from the air, and it can help in a garage you keep above freezing. Many models are made for warm rooms, so check the low-temperature limit in the specs before you buy one.

It treats the symptom, though. Ventilation or a flue deals with the cause, so set those up first and add a dehumidifier only if the garage still runs damp.

When dry air matters most

If you keep a car, a machine tool or a wall of hand tools in the garage, rust costs real money over a few winters. That is the garage where a vented heater earns its higher price in more than comfort.

The Big Maxx review covers the gas line, vent, wiring and LP conversion it needs, all work for a qualified installer. It is our pick for the best vented garage heater and for a permanent install, as the Big Maxx card sums up.

If you heat the garage only now and then, our top pick, the Big Buddy, costs far less and needs no installer. Its moisture stays in the garage, so the fresh-air openings matter even more.

If rust and wet floors are the problem

The Big Maxx sends its water vapor outside through a flue instead of into your garage, and it holds temperature on a wall thermostat. It is the priciest of the five and the install is a pro’s job, which pays off mainly when the garage holds tools or a car you want kept dry.

Questions and answers

More questions about condensation from a garage heater

Why does my garage get wet when I run a propane heater?

Burning propane makes water, about 1.6 lb for every pound of propane. An unvented heater leaves that vapor in the garage, and it condenses on the coldest surfaces, such as the slab, the windows and your tools.

How much water does a propane heater put into the air?

By arithmetic, a Big Buddy on high makes about 1.3 lb of water an hour, and a full 20 lb tank burned indoors leaves about 32 lb, close to 4 gallons, mostly as vapor.

Will a vent-free heater rust my tools?

It can, because all of its water vapor stays in the garage. Fresh-air openings help most, along with wiping and oiling bare steel and keeping good tools in a closed box.

Does a vented unit heater cause condensation?

Far less. A vented heater such as the Big Maxx sends its water vapor outside through the flue with the rest of the exhaust.

Should I seal the garage to keep the heat in?

Not with an unvented heater running. Sealing traps water vapor and carbon monoxide together. Keep the fresh-air openings your manual asks for and a battery CO alarm in the garage.